Am I Responsible for My Deceased Spouse’s Debts? And Other Questions Related to Creditors
Often, we come across clients who, when dealing with the death of their spouse, learn that their spouse owed a lot of debts to different creditors. What happens to these debts upon the death of a spouse? Is the surviving spouse responsible to pay these creditors back? How does the Estate handle payment of these creditors? This article will serve to answer these questions related to the rights of creditors after the death of your spouse.
Creditors’ Rights in Property When You Are Alive
In Virginia, married persons have the right to acquire, control, and dispose of property as if they are unmarried. Coupled with this right is that the property of either spouse is not subject to the debts and liabilities of the other spouse. Moreover, married persons have the right to contract and be contracted with and sue and be sued in the same manner and consequence as if they were unmarried.
The result of this is that a creditor may come after an individual or their property when the debt that is due is in that individual’s name only. If a creditor gets a judgment against a person, typically they will seek to attach a lien to the judgment debtor’s property. This is valid if the property is held solely in the debtor’s name.
Exceptions to General Rule
In some situations, Virginia does require that a spouse be jointly and severally liable for a debt incurred by their other spouse.
First, if you sign a contract in which you personally agree to pay for goods or service provided to your spouse, you will be responsible for paying any unpaid bills owed by your spouse.
Second, by law you are responsible to pay for emergency medical care provided to your spouse that remains due and owing, regardless of whether you agree to do so or not. Emergency medical care is defined as any care deemed necessary to preserve your spouse’s life and health which, if not rendered timely, can be reasonably anticipated to adversely affect your spouse’s recovery or imperil their life or health.
Third, even if you do not agree to such in writing, you are responsible to pay for any goods and services that are “necessary” to your spouse, which may open you up to liability for debts incurred by your spouse for both emergent and non-emergent treatment, among other “necessaries” under state law.
Tenancy by the Entireties vs. Joint Tenancy with Rights of Survivorship
If a property is owned by multiple people, the rights of creditors depend on how the property is titled. If the property owned is a martial home and is held as tenants by the entirety by a married couple, a creditor of only one of the spouses cannot attach a lien to the marital home. If a debt is owed by both spouses, a judgment lien can then attach to the marital home. However, the judgment against the spouses must be a joint judgment; if a creditor acquires two separate judgments against each individual spouse, that is insufficient to attach a judgment lien against property held in tenancy by the entireties. An exception to this rule is a federal tax lien, which can attach to one tenant’s rights in entireties property.
In addition to real property, multiple-party accounts between spouses can be held in tenancy by the entirety as long as it is explicit that the spouses are creating a joint account titled as “joint tenants with rights of survivorship.” If this is the case, then the account is not subject to a creditor claim for a debt owed by one spouse.
In addition, Virginia law provides that any property held as tenants by the entireties and conveyed to a revocable or irrevocable trust, either created jointly or individually, remains immune to creditor claims for individual debts as long as (a) the spouses remain married, (b) the property continues to be held in trust, and (c) both of the spouses are current beneficiaries of one trust that holds the property OR each of the spouses is a current beneficiary of a separate trust and the two separate trusts together hold the entire property, even if others are also beneficiaries of the separate trusts.
It is important to distinguish between a Tenancy by the Entireties and a Joint Tenancy with Right of Survivorship. Unlike in a Tenancy by the Entireties, a Joint Tenant has the right to sell their interest in the property. If the joint tenant does this, however, the right to survivorship is
severed and the creditor of the joint tenant may attach a lien to the tenant’s interest in the property. A creditor may even be able to force a partition of the property to satisfy their claim.
When it comes to joint accounts that are not held in tenancy by the entirety/with rights of survivorship, a joint account between spouses belongs to them equally, unless there is clear and convincing evidence of a different intent. If a creditor can show that a joint account primarily harbors funds from a single spouse, they may be able to attach a lien onto the account.
Other Nonprobate Assets
What about Payable-On-Death (POD) accounts?A POD account is a bank account that is titled so that at the death of the owner the account is automatically payable to a specified beneficiary. POD account holders who are spouses own the POD account equally. If one of the POD account holders owes a debt, their creditors can attach the POD account in accordance with
the debtor’s ownership interest.
Similarly, a Transfer on Death (TOD) account involves the registration of a brokerage or investment account to provide a transfer on death to designated beneficiaries. The TOD account belongs to an owner until death. If multiple owners create a TOD account, they must hold the asset with a right of survivorship or as tenants by the entireties. Since ownership does not pass to a beneficiary until the death of the owner, creditors have the same rights as they would have against owners of any multi-party account.
Group life insurance benefits are given extensive protection from creditor’s claims. The only instance when group life insurance benefits may be attachable is to enforce child and spousal support obligations. A person who is a beneficiary of the life insurance benefits, whether intended or not, is exempt from claims of the insured’s creditors so long as they are the spouse, dependent child, or any other person dependent on the person insured by the policy. Virginia law also provides creditor protection to a testamentary trustee who is designated as a life insurance beneficiary, as well as to any pension/retirement plans that are covered under ERISA. Nonetheless, a federal estate tax lien may be placed upon the proceeds of a life insurance policy if the proceeds are includible in a decedent’s estate.
Creditors’ Rights in Property Upon Death
If a debtor dies, a creditor generally must file a claim against the estate to seek repayment of a lawful debt that is due and owing against the decedent. The executor (typically the surviving spouse) is responsible for requesting that the Commissioner of Accounts schedule a Debts and Demands Hearing to allow creditors to appear and file their claims.
The Commissioner will then publish a notice of the hearing in a local newspaper and post the notice at the courthouse where the executor was appointed. Further, at least ten (10) days before the hearing, the executor is required to give notice of the hearing to any creditors having debts that the executor intends to contest. The executor must file proof of mailing of the notice of hearing with the Commissioner. After the hearing, the Commissioner will issue a report of the debts and demands that are deemed to be sufficiently proved and allowable.
The Virginia Code provides that an executor may be personally liable for any improper distributions, which is why it is in the executor’s interest to ensure that this process is adhered to.
When administering an estate, the executor is required to ensure that all lawful debts and obligations of the estate are be paid before any beneficiary receives their distribution from the estate. If the estate does not have enough funds to pay funeral expenses, administrative costs, debts, and legacies, the executor must sell so much of the remaining estate as is necessary to pay such obligations. In conducting a sale, the executor must give as much consideration as practicable to preserving any property or allowances payable to any beneficiaries.
If the estate does not have enough assets to satisfy the demands against the decedent, the assets must be paid in the following order:
- Costs and Expenses of Administration
- Exempt Property and Allowances
- Payment of up to $4,000 of funeral expenses
- Debts and Taxes owed to Federal Government
- Medical and Hospital expenses of the last illness of the decedent;
- Debts and Taxes owed to the Commonwealth of Virginia
- Other debts, taxes and claims
In general, it is best practice to wait to distribute assets to beneficiaries until all lawful creditor claims have been identified and paid from existing assets.
As you can see, there are many different rules pertaining to what property a creditor may come after to satisfy an unpaid debt. To determine how to best navigate your current financial situation, we highly recommend talking to an experienced estate planning and administration lawyer. We serve families living in Virginia, the District of Columbia, and Maryland. Call us at
571-500-7334 or send us an email at matt@degioialaw.com to schedule your initial consultation today!